Hartley LLP attorneys Jason Hartley and Jason Lindner have been named to the 2027 Best Lawyers® in America list. Best Lawyers® are designated through a peer-review process. Attorneys are divided by geographic region and practice areas and then reviewed by their peers on the basis of professional expertise.
News
Hartley LLP attorneys named to the 2027 Best Lawyers® in America list.Third Settlement Reached in MDI case with WanhuaClass Certified in Beef Price Fixing CaseClass Certified in Peeping Tom CasePreliminary approval of Tyson Beef settlement for $83.5 millionSecond settlement reached in MDI case with CovestroHartley LLP Recognized by Chambers for Antitrust ExcellenceSecond Settlement Reached in Monster Beef Antitrust LitigationIce-Breaker Settlement Reached in Diisocyanates CaseHartley LLP Defeats Zelis's Motions to DismissHartley LLP's Jasons Both Recognized as Super Lawyers®Jason Hartley published an article in the Daily Journal entitled "AI Pricing Algorithms are Anti-Competitive."Hartley LLP Elevates Maureen Forsyth to PartnerJason Hartley named to the Daily Journal's list of "Top Antitrust Lawyers"Jason Hartley named one of the San Diego Business Journal's 2025 "Leaders in Law."Hartley LLP Appointed Co-Lead Counsel in Zelis Antitrust LitigationHartley LLP Appointed to PowerSchool Data Breach LeadershipJason Hartley Recognized By Best Lawyers® In Two Practice AreasHartley LLP Snags Experienced Antitrust LitigatorZelis Healthcare Price FixingPowerSchool Data Breach NegligenceFrozen Potatoes Price FixingHartley LLP Appointed Co-Lead Counsel in Visa Debit CaseRecent Case ResultsJackson Hewitt No-Poach Case Settlement Obtains Preliminary Approval
July 10, 2026. After eight hard fought years of litigation, Plaintiffs have secured a third settlement in the MDI/TDI price fixing case. Following the pattern of the prior two settlements, this one increases both the amount of the settlement fund and the scope of cooperation Wanhua Chemical America, Inc. must provide in the case against the remaining defendants, Dow and Huntsman. Details of the settlement will be disclosed with the preliminary approval motion.
"We will continue to escalate our settlement demands with each subsequent defendant until we reach trial," said Hartley LLP partner, Jason Hartley.
Hartley LLP is co-lead counsel for Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs in the Diisocyanates antitrust price fixing MDL pending in the Western District of Pennsylvania.
July 16, 2026. Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs in the sprawling Cattle and Beef Antitrust Litigation were granted certification of their class action by the District of Minnesota today. Hartley LLP serves as one of the Court-appointed lead counsel for direct buyers of beef in the United States, one of five groups of plaintiffs pursuing antitrust claims against Cargill, National Beef, Tyson and JBS.
"This ruling impacts thousands of direct buyers and implicates billions of dollars of commerce," said Jason Hartley. "We look forward to moving past summary judgment and trying the case on behalf of our entire class against the remaining defendants."
July 10, 2026. Hartley LLP obtained certification of a class of female students at Los Osos High School who were victimized by a voyeur employed by the Chaffey Joint Union High School District. District employee David Riden admitted to placing "countless" cameras around the girls locker room, bathroom and other private areas at Los Osos High School from 2016 until he was caught in 2021. He was able to do so, despite having his recording devices found multiple times by other District employees.
"This was a righteous case to be certified," said Hartley LLP founder, Jason Hartley. "But the common issues coupled with a compelling economic theory of damages applicable to every student supported this correct ruling."
May 14, 2026. Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs' (DPP) second settlement in their Beef MDL obtained preliminary approval from the court in the District of Minnesota. The $83.5 million settlement brings a total settlement preliminarily approved for the DPP class to $135 million. Hartley LLP is co-lead counsel for the DPP class. The case continues against the remaining defendant, National Beef, and Cargill.
May 8, 2026. Following shortly after the first ice breaker settlement with BASF, Plaintiffs reached a second settlement with Covestro that is multiples of the first settlement.
"We look forward to obtaining approval of these two settlements from the Court and continuing to pursue our claims against the remaining defendants," said Hartley LLP partner, Jason Hartley.
Hartley LLP is co-lead counsel for Direct Purchaser Plaintiffs in the Diisocyanates antitrust price fixing MDL.
Hartley LLP was recognized today by Chambers and Partners Spotlight as one of a small number of Top Antitrust Law Firms in San Diego. Chambers Spotlight recognizes high-performing small-to-mid-sized law firms for providing specialized expertise, deep regional knowledge and partner-level attention to their clients. Ranked firms are chosen based on independent, in-depth market analysis and client feedback, rather than from the firms' self-submissions alone. It is a recognized resource for in-house counsel and businesses seeking boutique, high quality legal representation.
Chambers and Partners is a prominent London-based research company that produces independent, in-depth rankings and insights for the global legal industry.
Hartley LLP and its co-lead counsel, on behalf of direct purchasers of beef in the United States, reached the second settlement in the In re Cattle and Beef Antitrust Litigation pending in the District of Minnesota. Tyson Foods, Inc. and Tyson Fresh Meats, Inc. agreed to pay $82.5 million to settle claims it price fixed beef products with JBS, Cargill and National Beef. This settlement follows the first ice-breaker settlement with JBS of $52.5 million reached in 2022.
Plaintiffs will shortly be filing a preliminary approval motion with the Court and shall continue their litigation against the remaining Defendants, Cargill and National Beef.
The first settlement in the long-standing In re Diisocyanates Antitrust Litigation was reached today with the BASF Defendants. The case, filed in 2018, alleges a conspiracy between BASF, Covestro, Huntsman, Dow and Wanhua to fix the prices of diisocyanates, colloquially known as MDI and TDI, in the United States since at least 2016. Diisocyanates are ubiquitous chemicals used in the manufacture of urethanes and foam products ranging from cast wheels, to foam mattresses, to coatings, adhesive and sealants.
The details of the settlement will be made public upon the filing of the preliminary approval motion next month. Plaintiffs expect this ice-breaker settlement to lead to further settlements with the remaining Defendants.
The District of Massachusetts denied almost entirely the motions to dismiss brought by Zelis and its health insurance co-Defendants in an antitrust case alleging a horizontal conspiracy to reduce the payments to doctors who provide services to patients who are the insurance Defendants members. Despite Zelis's bald and baseless claim in a press release that "the plaintiffs' lawyers failed to conduct a diligent investigation before filing their claims," the Court agreed with the viability of the allegations made in Plaintiffs' 162-page complaint.
"The complaint was one of the most thorough, well-researched complaints I have seen at this stage of an antitrust case," said Jason Hartley, noting that it was filed before a single piece of evidence was developed in discovery.
Plaintiffs look forward to vindicating their claims as the litigation continues.
Jason Hartley and Jason Lindner, the founding partners of Hartley LLP, were both recognized by Super Lawyers®. Super Lawyers® is a rating service of outstanding lawyers from several practice areas who have attained high peer recognition and professional achievement. The annual selection process includes nominations, peer evaluations and third-party research, resulting in a list that features no more than 5% of lawyers in any given state.
This is Jason Hartley's 14th year of recognition as a Super Lawyer in the areas of Antitrust Law, Class Action, and Entertainment Law and Jason Lindner's 12th year of recognition in the areas of Antitrust Litigation, Consumer Law and Labor and Employment.
Jason Hartley published an article in the Daily Journal entitled "AI Pricing Algorithms are Anti-Competitive." The article, published in the November 26, 2025 issue, elaborates California's new law, effective January 2026, condemning third party pricing algorithms as violations of the Cartwright Act. It explains why horizontal competitors' surrendering pricing authority to a common third party hurts competition and should be similarly condemned by the Sherman Act.
Hartley LLP Elevates Maureen Forsyth to Partner
San Diego, California (January 1, 2026): Hartley LLP is pleased to announce that Maureen Forsyth has been elevated to Partner, recognizing her exceptional contributions to the firm, her leadership, and her exceptional legal work on complex, high-stakes matters.
Maureen joined Hartley LLP nearly four years ago and has quickly distinguished herself as a smart, hardworking, and highly capable attorney. She is especially adept at managing large, nationwide class actions involving tens of millions of documents, bringing rigor, organization, and strategic insight to some of the firm's most demanding cases. Beyond her technical excellence, Maureen is known for her positivity, friendliness, and professionalism. She is a true team player—loyal, thoughtful, and consistently exercising strong judgment—who elevates every matter she touches.
"We couldn't be prouder to have Maureen represent the firm in her cases," said Jason Hartley, founding partner of Hartley LLP. "She is a delight to work with and generates only the best work product."
Maureen brings a wide array of experience to her new role as partner. Her practice spans antitrust, class actions, consumer protection, shareholder and securities litigation, government contracts, and debt recovery. She has played a key role in legal strategy and case development for both individual and business clients, including coordinating a large antitrust class action between six plaintiff groups and preparing for apex depositions of Fortune 500 defendant executives. Prior to joining Hartley LLP, Maureen practiced in one of the largest plaintiff firms in the country.
Maureen earned her J.D. from Suffolk University Law School in 1999, where she was on the Dean's List, and her B.A. from the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, graduating cum laude with a dual degree in Legal Studies and English.
Hartley LLP congratulates Maureen Forsyth on this well-deserved achievement and looks forward to her continued leadership and success as a partner of the firm.
Jason Hartley has been named to the Daily Journal's list of "Top Antitrust Lawyers" for 2025. Daily Journal subscribers can read a recent profile on Jason and his practice here: https://www.dailyjournal.com/articles/388702
Congratulations, Jason!
Congratulations to Jason Hartley, who was named as one of the San Diego Business Journal's 2025 "Leaders in Law." You can read about Jason and all of the honorees here: https://sdbusinessjournal.pressreader.com/san-diego-business-journal
Hartley LLP Appointed Co-Lead Counsel in Zelis Antitrust Litigation
Jason Hartley was appointed co-lead counsel by Judge Murphy in the District of Massachusetts in the class action antitrust lawsuit against the medical billing company Zelis. This case alleges a conspiracy among medical and dental insurers and their billing company, Zelis, to systematically underpay doctors and healthcare professionals for out-of-network care by sharing confidential proprietary pricing and other data.
Judge Murphy stated that he believed that Hartley LLP and co-lead counsel, Paul LLP, have the "experience, resources, and ability to fairly and efficiently represent the interests of the putative class."
Hartley LLP Appointed to PowerSchool Data Breach Leadership
Hartley LLP was appointed to the Plaintiffs Steering Committee by Judge Benitez in the Southern District of California in this sprawling data breach case on behalf of tens of millions of individuals. PowerSchool provides cloud-based software for K-12 education in the United States. In that role, it collects highly sensitive and confidential PII (personal identifiable information) including the health, parent/guardian phone numbers and tax ID information of over 60 million students, parents, and school faculty worldwide.
In December 2024, PowerSchool permitted that PII to be stolen through a data breach that affected not only PowerSchool's subscribers but also persons who had no relationship with PowerSchool and never consented to it collecting and storing their PII. Most of the accessed PII included information pertaining to students under the age of 18.
Jason Hartley Recognized By Best Lawyers® In Two Practice Areas
We are proud to announce Hartley LLP Founder Jason Hartley was named to the 2026 Best Lawyers® List in both the Consumer Protection Law and Class Actions/Mass Tort – Plaintiffs practice areas. Best Lawyers® are designated through a peer-review process. Attorneys are divided by geographic region and practice areas and then reviewed by their peers on the basis of professional expertise.
June, 2024: Hartley LLP is delighted to announce that Ken Frost, a seasoned antitrust and class action litigator with decades of experience, has joined the firm. Ken has worked on antitrust class actions with Hartley LLP attorneys for decades while he practiced at a renowned San Francisco-based firm.
Hartley LLP filed the first and proprietary case against Zelis and health insurers for creating a conspiracy to fix and artificially suppress prices of healthcare services paid to healthcare providers for performing "out-of-network" healthcare services.
Hartley LLP filed a negligence case against PowerSchool for a data breach affecting the private information of tens of millions of Americans. PowerSchool provides cloud-based software for K-12 education in the United States. In that role, it collects highly sensitive and confidential PII (personal identifiable information) including the health, parent/guardian phone numbers and tax ID information of over 60 million students, parents, and school faculty worldwide.
In December 2024, PowerSchool permitted that PII to be stolen through a data breach that affected not only PowerSchool's subscribers but also persons who had no relationship with PowerSchool and never consented to it collecting and storing their PII. Most of the accessed PII included information pertaining to students under the age of 18.
Hartley LLP filed a complaint on behalf of a class of commercial and institutional payers alleging price fixing in the frozen potato market. The case alleges the four largest frozen potato food processors, McCain Foods, Lamb Weston, J.R. Simplot and Cavendish Farms, which control 98% of the market for frozen french fries, tater tots, hash browns and other potato products used by restaurants, maintained an illegal agreement to inflate the prices of those products.
The producers engaged in identical price hikes since 2021. Restaurants have no other competitively-priced source for those products given the defendants' dominance in the market.
December 16, 2024: This month, Judge John G. Koeltl of the Southern District of New York appointed Hartley LLP as co-lead counsel for the plaintiff cardmember class in the Visa Debit card case. Plaintiffs allege Visa monopolized the market for debit card network services and entered into anticompetitive agreements with competitors and potential competitors to not enter the market, thus eliminating competition.
The Department of Justice is pursuing a parallel criminal case against Visa in the same District, which case has been coordinated with the civil cases.
Hartley LLP is pleased to announce its recent class action case results:
Jackson Hewitt: In the District of New Jersey, Hartley LLP, along with its co-lead counsel, secured final approval of a settlement with Jackson Hewitt regarding antitrust allegations surrounding its no-poach policy. It is the first and only settlement of a case alleging a no-poach conspiracy intrabrand, between a franchisor and its franchisees.
Packaged Seafood: Hartley LLP was part of a Court-appointed leadership team for a class of direct purchasers of packaged seafood products. The long-running case was first filed in 2015, and recent settlements with Starkist, DWI, Lion Capital Americas Inc. and Big Catch Cayman LP were approved for over $38 million in cash along with over $26 million in product. The class previously settled with Chicken of the Sea and the only other defendant, Bumble Bee, filed for bankruptcy.
Varsity Cheer: Hartley LLP and its court appointed co-counsel for the class obtained final approval of an $82.5 million settlement on behalf of families victimized by Varsity Cheer's monopolization of the competitive cheer and apparel markets. The class consists of families that indirectly paid Varsity for cheer competitions, camps, and/or apparel. In addition to the monetary settlement fund, Varsity committed to injunctive relief that is intended to permit more competition in the competitive cheer market.
We are thrilled to secure such significant results for each class. For more information on Hartley LLP's class action work, visit our website at www.hartleyllp.com.
Jackson Hewitt No-Poach Case Settlement Obtains Preliminary Approval
After five and a half years of litigation, Hartley LLP reached a settlement with Jackson Hewitt on behalf of a class of tax preparers who worked at Jackson Hewitt corporate stores. The settlement was approved on July 3, 2024 by Judge Michael E. Farbiarz in the District of New Jersey.
The tax preparers alleged an illegal conspiracy among Jackson Hewitt companies not to solicit or poach each other's tax preparer employees. The effect of these agreements was to depress employees' wages, restrict their ability to move jobs, and limited their leverage to negotiate better pay.
The settlement of $10,800,000 represents 100% of the damages calculated by plaintiffs' expert based on the total data produced in the case. The hearing on final approval is set for October 11, 2024.
Jackson Hewitt Anti-Poaching: Hartley LLP filed an antitrust class action against the tax preparing firm Jackson Hewitt. The complaint alleges an illegal conspiracy among Jackson Hewitt companies not to solicit or poach each other's employees. The effect of these agreements was to depress employees' wages, restrict their ability to move jobs, and limited their leverage to negotiate better pay.
The damaging effect was emphasized by the fact that these workers had a unique skillset with the Jackson Hewitt model that made defendants natural alternative employers for these workers across more than 6,000 locations. The case is pending in the District of New Jersey.
Hartley LLP represents individuals and companies in antitrust and unfair competition cases. If you feel you were a victim of anticompetitive conduct, contact us here.